9/19/09
Evilbible - the Polemical Saga Continues, part 4 of 5
Please note: this essay has been moved to True Freethinker at this link.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
You can visit my new homepage, True Freethinker, via this feed
Get my ebook, "The Apocryphal Jesus," here
The Following Personages are in the AiD Hizouse
Archive
To be found in the AiD hizouse
- 2012 (1)
- 365 Quick Answers to Key Questions (1)
- 5-Minute Apologetics for Today (1)
- 9/11 (1)
- A. J. Jacobs (1)
- Abby Johnson (1)
- abiogenesis (3)
- abortion (2)
- abortion clinic bombing (1)
- About.com (5)
- abstinence (1)
- academy of apologetics (1)
- Adolf Hitler (32)
- ads (1)
- Afghanistan (1)
- agnostics (1)
- aha (4)
- Aidan Maconachy (2)
- Aikman (1)
- Alain de Botton (1)
- Alan Dundes (1)
- Alan Watts (1)
- Albert Einstein (1)
- Alfred Russel Wallace (1)
- Alfred Russell Wallace (1)
- alien (7)
- alister mcgrath (5)
- Allah (1)
- altruism (1)
- Alvin Plantinga (1)
- Amanda Metskas (1)
- american atheists (7)
- American Atheists National Convention (1)
- American Humanist Association (4)
- American Humanists Association (5)
- American vision (2)
- Amish (4)
- Amish friendship bread (4)
- Amish paradise (4)
- An American Carole (1)
- An Atheist's Guide to Christmas (2)
- and the Bible (1)
- Andrew Denton (1)
- Andrew Motion (1)
- Andrew Newberg (1)
- anglican cathedral (1)
- Ann Coulter (1)
- Ann Curry (1)
- Anne Frank (1)
- Anne Nicol Gaylor (2)
- Annie Gaylor (1)
- Annie Laurie Gaylor (6)
- answering atheism (8)
- anthropic principle (3)
- anthropology (8)
- anti-Semitism (1)
- anti-theist (1)
- antony (1)
- antony flew (1)
- AOMin (1)
- apatheism (1)
- apologetic (2)
- apologetics (82)
- Apologetics 315 (13)
- Apologetics Press (1)
- Arbeit Macht Frei (1)
- Archaeopteryx (2)
- Archaeoraptor liaoningensis (1)
- Archbishop of Canterbury (1)
- arguments for atheism (1)
- argumentum ad Hitlerum (1)
- argumentum ad Nazium (1)
- Ariane Sherine (5)
- Aristotle (1)
- arizona atheist (5)
- Articles (3)
- Asking the Right God Questions (2)
- astronomy (1)
- Athanatos (2)
- atheism (535)
- atheism and science (10)
- atheism bus ads (1)
- atheism in the name of God (1)
- atheism is dead (3)
- Atheism Quotes (2)
- atheism spirituality (1)
- Atheism Symbols (1)
- atheist (179)
- Atheist Alliance International (7)
- atheist bus ads (2)
- Atheist Community of Topeka (3)
- Atheist Experience (1)
- Atheist Foundation of Australia (2)
- Atheist Quotes (2)
- atheist Sunday school (1)
- Atheist Symbols (1)
- Atheist T-Shirts (1)
- athiest (1)
- Atlas of Creation (1)
- audio (4)
- audio bible (2)
- Auguste Comte (1)
- Auschwitz . (1)
- Austin (1)
- Austin Cline (5)
- Austin Dacey (2)
- Australopithecus (3)
- Ava Isabella Stinson (1)
- Bahnsen (1)
- baptism (1)
- Barack Obama (3)
- Barak Obama (5)
- Barker (4)
- Barna Group (1)
- Barney Frank (1)
- Bart Ehrman (8)
- behe (1)
- belief (1)
- Ben Stein (1)
- Benjamin Wiker (2)
- benny hinn (1)
- Benveniste (1)
- Berlinski (1)
- Bertrand Russell (4)
- Bess Twiston Davies (1)
- Beverly Hills Chihuahua (1)
- bible (227)
- bible ten commandments (3)
- big bang (2)
- bill boards (1)
- Bill Honsberger (1)
- bill maher (11)
- Bill Maher controversy (1)
- Bill Muehlenberg (1)
- Bill Vallicella (1)
- biology (11)
- BOBA (2)
- book (2)
- book review (1)
- books (7)
- Boris Talantov (1)
- Born believers: How your brain creates God (1)
- Boteach (1)
- Brad Pitt (1)
- breaking the spell (4)
- Breaking the Spell: Religion as a Natural Phenomenon (1)
- Brian Flemming (1)
- brian sapient (1)
- bright (33)
- Brights (4)
- British Humanist Association (1)
- Buddha (1)
- buddhism (2)
- bus ads (15)
- C S Lewis (4)
- cafepress (1)
- California Science Center (2)
- Camille Paglia (1)
- camp quest (5)
- Capella’s Guide to Atheism (2)
- carl sagan (4)
- Celebrity Atheists Expose Their Hypocrisy (1)
- censorship (2)
- Chamberlain (14)
- charity (3)
- charled darwin (1)
- Charles Bradlaugh (1)
- Charles Darwin (15)
- Charles Symoni (1)
- Charlie H. Campbell (1)
- Charlie Sitzes (1)
- Charlotte Allen (1)
- children (2)
- Chris Weitz (1)
- Chrisitniaty (2)
- christian apologetics (131)
- Christianity (161)
- christmas (3)
- Christopher (1)
- christopher hitchens (48)
- classroom (1)
- Cliff Walker (17)
- Cline (1)
- CMI (15)
- Cobb County (1)
- Coelacanth (1)
- Cold Fusion (1)
- collateral (1)
- collision (1)
- Columbine (1)
- Columbine High School (1)
- comics (1)
- Committee for the Scientific Investigation of Claims of the Paranormal (2)
- communism (2)
- Communist Russia (1)
- Conan (1)
- Concise Responses to the Top 40 Questions (1)
- consciousness (1)
- Conservatives (1)
- Copernicus (3)
- cosmological argument (1)
- cosmology (21)
- Craig (2)
- Craig James (1)
- creation (6)
- Creation Ministries International (1)
- creation science (1)
- creationism (6)
- Cremo (3)
- Crocker (1)
- cruise (1)
- CSICOP (8)
- current events (1)
- Dan (1)
- dan barker (70)
- Dan Barker Freedom From Religion Foundation (1)
- dan darker (1)
- Dan P. McAdams (1)
- Daniel Dennet (2)
- daniel dennett (33)
- Daniel Drasin (2)
- Danny Glover (1)
- Darwin (20)
- darwin was wrong (1)
- darwin’s dilemma (4)
- Darwin's theory of evolution (1)
- Darwinian theory (1)
- Darwinism (4)
- David Bentley Hart (1)
- David Boulton (1)
- David Letterman (1)
- David Pilbeam (1)
- Dawkins (9)
- de-baptism (1)
- Dean Hamer (1)
- Dean Radin (1)
- debate (28)
- Debates (2)
- debunking (1)
- Debunking Christianity (1)
- declaration of Independence (1)
- deconvert (1)
- DeMar (1)
- Dembski (2)
- Dennett (1)
- Dennett Daniel (1)
- Dennis McKinsey (2)
- Dennis Rawlins (1)
- Design (3)
- designer (1)
- despair (1)
- Devil’s Chaplain (1)
- Dictatorial (1)
- Dinesh D'Souza (5)
- discover institute (1)
- discovery institute (6)
- diversity (1)
- DNA (1)
- do aliens exist (1)
- don’t label me (2)
- Donald Johanson (1)
- Donald Protheros (1)
- Doug Wilson (1)
- Dover (1)
- download (1)
- ductio ad Hitlerum (1)
- Duncan Derrett (5)
- Dvir Abramovich (1)
- Dylan Klebold (1)
- earth (1)
- Easter Challenge (1)
- ebook (1)
- edward feser (1)
- Edwin Hubble (1)
- einstein (1)
- Emerging Church (1)
- end of faith (3)
- epileptologists (1)
- Eric Harris (1)
- Essays (3)
- ethical culturalists (1)
- ethics (54)
- Eugenie Scott (2)
- Evan Fales (5)
- evidence (1)
- evil (6)
- evil bible (1)
- evilbibl.com (7)
- evilbible (33)
- evilbible.com (44)
- evilbile (1)
- evolution (28)
- Ex-Christian (4)
- Ex-Christian.Net (7)
- ExChristian (8)
- ExChristian.net (5)
- exclusivity (1)
- Expelled (2)
- Expelled Exposed (1)
- Expelled: No Intelligence Allowed (1)
- faith (1)
- ffrf (7)
- Fichte (14)
- fiction (1)
- fine tuning (1)
- flat (1)
- Flying Spaghetti Monster (5)
- Forbidden Archeology (3)
- Fossil (1)
- fossils (1)
- Four Horsemen (13)
- foxx (1)
- Francis Collins (4)
- Francis Crick (3)
- Frank Turek (1)
- Fred Hoyle (2)
- Free Republic (13)
- freedom from religion foundation (32)
- Freethinker (35)
- Freethinkers (3)
- Freethought (41)
- Freethought Society of Greater Philadelphia (1)
- Friedrich Nietzsche (6)
- funderal (1)
- G. K. Chesterton (1)
- Galileo (2)
- Galileo Galilei (1)
- gary demar (1)
- Gay Marriage (1)
- general revelation (1)
- genesis (1)
- George Abell (1)
- George Francis (1)
- George Johnson (1)
- George Tiller (1)
- George Washington (1)
- George Winston (1)
- Gigantoraptor (1)
- Giordano Bruno (1)
- Global Atheist Convention (1)
- Global Warming (1)
- Gobineau (1)
- God (194)
- God Delusion (15)
- God is Dead (1)
- God is not great (1)
- God Is Not Great: How Religion Poisons Everything (2)
- God’s problem (1)
- God's ten commandments (3)
- Godless (2)
- Gordon Stein (1)
- Gospel of Judas (1)
- gould (2)
- Greg Bahnsen (1)
- Gregory Rodriguez (1)
- Gregory S. Paul (1)
- Greydon Square (1)
- Groothuis (1)
- Guardian (1)
- Guillermo Gonzalez (1)
- Guthrie (1)
- Haeckel (14)
- haiti (3)
- Haiti and the Hypocrisy of Christian Theology (1)
- Halton Arp (1)
- Harold C. Urey (1)
- Harold P. Klein (1)
- Harris (2)
- Harry Potter (1)
- Harun Yahya (1)
- HBO (1)
- healthcare (1)
- heaven (1)
- Hector Avalos (1)
- Hegel (14)
- hell (5)
- Higgs Boson (1)
- Hillary Clinton (1)
- hip hop (1)
- His Dark Materials (2)
- historical Jesus (1)
- History of Atheism (1)
- hitchens (1)
- hitler (4)
- Hitler's Ethic: The Nazi Pursuit of Evolutionary Progress (1)
- Holocaust (16)
- Homo habilis (1)
- homonid (3)
- Hugh Ross (1)
- human sacrifice (1)
- Humanism (39)
- Humanist (4)
- Humanist and Secular Student Societies (1)
- Humanist Foundation (1)
- Humanist Manifesto (1)
- Humanist Society of Scotland (1)
- humanists (1)
- I Don't Have Enough Faith to Be an Atheist (1)
- Ida (1)
- If There's A God (1)
- Illuminati (1)
- imagine (1)
- In the beginning (1)
- Indiana Atheist Bus Campaign (2)
- Indiana Daily Student (1)
- Infidel Guy (1)
- Intelligent (1)
- Intelligent Design (23)
- internet infidels (2)
- Invisible Pink Unicorns (5)
- Irreligion (1)
- Is the Bible Sexist New research claims Bible's negative stance on women is a myth (1)
- islam (3)
- itheism (1)
- itheist (1)
- J. P. Moreland (1)
- JAMA (1)
- James Hartle (1)
- James Randi (9)
- James Robert Brown (1)
- James Van Brunn (1)
- James Von Brunn (2)
- James White (1)
- Jamie Glazov (1)
- Jan Williams (1)
- Jason Gastrich (2)
- Jay Richards (2)
- Jean-Jacques Rousseau (1)
- Jeffery Jay Lowder (1)
- Jeffery Lowder (5)
- Jeffrey Dahmer (1)
- Jeninne Lee-St. John (1)
- Jerry Coyne (1)
- jerry falwell (1)
- Jerry Fodor (1)
- Jesus (158)
- Jesus interrupted (1)
- Jobs For Philosophers (1)
- Joe Keysor (2)
- JOE SCARBOROUGH (1)
- Joel McDurmon (1)
- Johannes Kepler (1)
- John Allen Paulos (1)
- John Cleese (2)
- John Gray (1)
- John Horgan (1)
- john lennon (2)
- John Lennox (1)
- John Loftus (3)
- John Maddox (1)
- John Preston (1)
- John W. Loftus (2)
- Jonas Alexis (1)
- Joseph Stalin (1)
- Journal of Religion and Society (1)
- jp holding (1)
- Jr. (2)
- Judaism (1)
- juju (1)
- Julia Sweeney (1)
- Julian Huxley (1)
- Julius Rebek (1)
- kalam cosmological argument (1)
- Kant (14)
- Karen Armstrong (2)
- Karl Marx (2)
- KBS Tuff (1)
- Keith (1)
- Keith Parsons (5)
- Ken Bronstein (1)
- Kirk Cameron (1)
- Klaas Hendrikse (1)
- Koran (1)
- Kreeft (1)
- kyle butt (4)
- larry charles (2)
- laws of nature (1)
- Lectures (8)
- Lee Tibbetts (1)
- Lennox (1)
- letter to a christian nation (2)
- Letter to a Secular Nation (1)
- Lewis Wolpert (1)
- lewontin (1)
- Liberal (1)
- Life After Death: The Evidence (1)
- Lisa Miller (1)
- list of the ten commandments (3)
- Loftus (1)
- logic (11)
- london (1)
- london bus (1)
- Los Angeles Times (1)
- Losing Faith in Faith (1)
- MacGyverJr (1)
- Madeleine Bunting (1)
- magic (1)
- Mahmud Ahmadinejad (1)
- Malta (1)
- man created God (1)
- Manata (1)
- Mao (1)
- Marcello Truzzi (3)
- Margaret Downey (2)
- Margarita Lacabe (1)
- Martin (1)
- Martin Gardner (1)
- Marvin Zelen (1)
- Massimo Piattelli-Palmarini (1)
- Massimo Pigliucci (2)
- materialism (3)
- Mathews (1)
- Matt Dillahunty (1)
- Matt Slick (1)
- Matthew Cobb (1)
- Maverick Philosopher (1)
- McCain (1)
- McGrath (1)
- McMaster Children’s Hospital (1)
- Meaning (3)
- media (1)
- Mein Kampf (14)
- Melanie Phillips (1)
- meme (1)
- memetics (1)
- Messiah (1)
- Methodology (1)
- Metroplex Atheists (3)
- Michael De Dora (2)
- Michael Egnor (1)
- michael martin (7)
- Michael Newdow (3)
- Michael Poole (1)
- Michael Ruse (3)
- Michael Shermer (8)
- Michel Gauquelin (1)
- Michelle Albaugh (1)
- Midwest Atheist (3)
- Mike Adams (1)
- Mike Williams (1)
- Miksa (1)
- Miksa's Musings (1)
- Militant Religious Fundamentalism (1)
- millions are good without God (1)
- miracles (14)
- miracles resurrectio (1)
- Misquoting Jesus (9)
- Missing Link (1)
- MIT (1)
- Mitch Daniels (2)
- monotheism (1)
- Monsters vs Aliens (1)
- moral (2)
- morality (52)
- morals (53)
- Moreland (1)
- Morey (1)
- morphology (1)
- Moses (1)
- Mother Teresa (1)
- Mother Teresa stamp (1)
- mp3 (3)
- multiverse (2)
- Muslim (2)
- myers (2)
- nanking (1)
- NASA (2)
- Nathan Schneider (1)
- National Bible Week (7)
- National Center for Science Education (1)
- National Federation of Atheist (1)
- National Geographic (1)
- National Institutes of Health (1)
- National Public Radio (1)
- National Secular Society (1)
- nativity (1)
- natural laws (1)
- natural selection (3)
- natural theology (1)
- naturalism (2)
- Nazi (33)
- Near-Death Experiences (1)
- Neil Estep (1)
- Neo Paganism (1)
- Netherlands (1)
- Neurotheologians (1)
- new (1)
- new atheism (10)
- new atheist (158)
- new atheist Christopher Hitchens (3)
- New Atheists (82)
- new athiest (5)
- new testament (1)
- New York City Atheists (1)
- new york times (1)
- news (3)
- Newsweek (1)
- Nica Lalli (3)
- Nicholas Humphrey (4)
- Nietzsche (15)
- NIH (1)
- no god no problem (1)
- norm geisler (3)
- Norman Geisler (1)
- Northwestern University (1)
- NPR (1)
- Obama (1)
- Oleg Dei (1)
- One-Minute Answers to Skeptics (1)
- Orgel (1)
- Origin of Species (1)
- Our Mutual Joy (1)
- Owen Gingerich (1)
- paleoanthropology (2)
- Palin (1)
- Pandora’s Box (1)
- Pandorum (1)
- Parable of the Mad Man (3)
- Parenting Beyond Belief (1)
- Parsons (1)
- Pat Robertson (1)
- Paul Broun (1)
- Paul Case (2)
- Paul Kurtz (1)
- Pekka-Eric Auvinen (1)
- penn and teller (1)
- penn jillett (1)
- Penta (1)
- Peter Kay (1)
- Peter Kirby (5)
- Peter popoff (1)
- Peter Williams (1)
- Phelps (1)
- phil fernandez (1)
- Philip Johnson (1)
- Philip Pullman (5)
- Philip Skell (1)
- Philosophical (1)
- philosophy (16)
- Physics (1)
- planned parenthood (1)
- Plantinga (2)
- please don’t label me (1)
- Please Don’t Label Me A (1)
- podcast (1)
- Politics (1)
- positive (1)
- Positive Atheism (21)
- postmodernism (1)
- Posts (3)
- Presuppositional Apologetics Stated and Defended (1)
- presuppositionalism (1)
- problem of evil (10)
- propaganda (1)
- provine (1)
- Pslams (1)
- Psychology Today (2)
- Psychoneuroimmunology (1)
- Purpose (3)
- PZ (2)
- PZ Myers (12)
- Quentin Smith (8)
- quotes (1)
- qur'an (1)
- Quran (1)
- R.C. Sproul (1)
- Rabbi (1)
- Ramapithecus (4)
- rap (1)
- rape (11)
- rape morals (6)
- Rational Thought (1)
- Rationalism (1)
- rationalists (1)
- Ray Comfort (1)
- real time (1)
- Real Time with Bill Maher (1)
- reductio ad Nazium (1)
- reductionism (3)
- Reed Guy (1)
- Reflection on Tough Questions of Faith (1)
- Reginald Finley (1)
- religion (10)
- religious violence (1)
- Religulous (3)
- resurrection (6)
- Richard Bozarth (1)
- richard carrier (7)
- Richard darkens (2)
- Richard Dawkins (101)
- Richard Kammann (1)
- richard leakey (1)
- richard lewontin (3)
- Richard PZ Myers (1)
- Richard Sternberg (1)
- Richard Weikart (1)
- RichardDawkins.net (13)
- Rise of Atheism in America (6)
- Rita De Alverez (1)
- RNA (1)
- rob sherman (2)
- Robert Deltete (1)
- Robert Greg Cavin (5)
- robert jastrow (1)
- Robert M. Price (1)
- Robert Marks (1)
- Robert Morey (1)
- Robert Park (4)
- Robert Price (5)
- Robert T. Carroll (1)
- Rochus Boerner (6)
- Roland Emmerich (1)
- Ron Nurwisah (1)
- Ron Rhodes (2)
- Rowan Williams (1)
- Royal Ontario Museum (3)
- rushdie (1)
- Ruth Gledhill (2)
- Sam Harris (45)
- Samantha Stein (1)
- Sarah Palin (1)
- Sceptics's Guide to New Atheism (1)
- schadenfreude (1)
- Schopenhauer (14)
- science (70)
- Science Center (1)
- Science Club of Long Island (1)
- Scienceblogs (1)
- Scientific American (4)
- Scott F. Gilbert (1)
- Scott Todd (1)
- Sean Hannity (1)
- Seattle Atheists (4)
- Seattle Weekly (1)
- Secular (1)
- Secular Coalition (1)
- secular humanists (1)
- Secular Humanists of the Lowcountry (1)
- secularism (2)
- Seeing Red (1)
- seinfeld (1)
- selfish gene (1)
- sex (1)
- sexuality (1)
- Sigmund Freud (1)
- Six Impossible Things Before Breakfast: The Evolutionary Origins of Belief (1)
- skeptic (11)
- Skeptic’s Annotated Bible (1)
- Skeptic's Dictionary (1)
- Skeptic’s Dictionary (1)
- Skepticism (5)
- skeptics (1)
- slavery (2)
- Smithsonian (1)
- SMRT (1)
- society (1)
- solstice (1)
- Sourcebook Project (1)
- soviet (1)
- spirituality (1)
- stalin (1)
- StatGuy (1)
- Stein (1)
- Stephen Barrett (1)
- Stephen F. Uhl (1)
- Stephen Hawking (1)
- Stephen Jay Gould (1)
- Stephen Kingsley (1)
- Stephen Meyer (3)
- Stephen Tyrone Johns (1)
- Sternberg (1)
- Steve Weinberg (1)
- Storrs L. Olson (1)
- suffering (2)
- Sunday School for Atheists (1)
- supernatural (1)
- Susan B. Anthony (1)
- Swedish Humanist Association (1)
- Sydney Harris (1)
- Tabash (1)
- Tags: Bart Ehrman (2)
- Taliban (1)
- Tasmania (1)
- televangelist (1)
- Telling Lies for Atheism (1)
- ten commandments (1)
- Terrorism And Militant Religious Fundamentalism (1)
- terrorist (1)
- Terry Sanderson (1)
- the amazing Randi (2)
- The Atheist's Guide to Christmas (1)
- The Bible Among the Myths (1)
- The Biblical male and housework Faith Online's guide to men (1)
- The Blackwell Companion to Natural Theology (1)
- The Church of Theists Suck (6)
- The Darwin Myth: the Life and Lies of Charles Darwin (1)
- The Encyclopedia of Biblical Errancy (1)
- The End of Faith (2)
- The God Delusion (3)
- The God I Don’t Understand (1)
- The Golden Compass (2)
- The Greatest Show on Earth (1)
- The Greatest Show on Earth: The Evidence for Evolution (1)
- The Holocaust (1)
- The Long Journey of My De-Conversion (1)
- The New Atheism 10 Arguments That Don't Hold Water (1)
- The New Atheism and the Erosion of Freedom (1)
- The New York Times (1)
- The Return of the Village Atheist (1)
- The Rise of Atheism (1)
- The Root of All Evil (1)
- The Truth Delusion of Richard Dawkins (1)
- the wedge document (2)
- The World's Most Dangerous Book (1)
- theism (13)
- theists suck (6)
- Theodore Drange (5)
- Theodosius Dobzhansky (1)
- theology (14)
- theory of evolution (14)
- thermodynamics (1)
- Thomas Henry Huxley (1)
- thomas jefferson (2)
- tiananmen square massacre (1)
- Tiger Woods (1)
- Timothy McVeigh (1)
- tolerance (1)
- Totalitarian (1)
- Townhall.com (1)
- TracieH (1)
- transitional form (1)
- Trinity (2)
- Truthbomb Apologetics (1)
- Tufts University (1)
- tweet (1)
- twitter (1)
- Tydto Brahe (1)
- Tyrannical (1)
- U.S. Census (1)
- UFO (2)
- universe (3)
- Universism (1)
- Urey Miller (1)
- USA Today (1)
- Valerie Tarico (1)
- Van Brunn (1)
- Victor Reppert (1)
- video (1)
- Videos (1)
- Virginia ... There is no God (1)
- Vitz (1)
- Voltaire (14)
- Vox Day (3)
- Voyage the Shook the World (1)
- Wagner (14)
- walker (1)
- Walter L. Porter (1)
- Walter Sinnott-Armstrong (1)
- Warranted Christian Belief (1)
- Wedge document (2)
- What Darwin Got Wrong (1)
- What shall we tell the children (4)
- Why Are There Atheists? (1)
- Wiker (1)
- William F. Harrison (1)
- william lane craig (14)
- William Long and George Tiller (1)
- William Provine (2)
- William R. Corliss (1)
- Women and Children’s Hospital (1)
- Work Will Set You Free (1)
- worldview (1)
- Year of the Bible (1)
- Yes (1)
- You can be good without God (1)
- Zacharias (1)
- Zarathushtra (1)
- Zogby (1)
- Zoroaster (1)
- Zorro (1)
No comments:
Post a Comment